Home › Guides › Should I file a homeowners insurance claim? What to know before you decide
Should I file a homeowners insurance claim? What to know before you decide
There is no single right answer to whether to file a homeowners insurance claim, and this page does not give one. It sets out what to find out first: the real repair cost, the deductible that applies, how your policy expects a loss reported, and how claims history is used. The decision stays with you. If water is still spreading, get help now and decide later.

Decide with numbers, not a first look
Before deciding whether to file, get a written repair estimate, find your deductible on the declarations page, and ask your agent how a claim is handled on your policy and in your state. The NAIC's advice: before reporting the property damage to your home, find out what your deductible is. Then weigh the numbers against what is still unknown.
| Factor | What to find out | Where the answer comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Repair cost | A written repair or restoration estimate, including damage you can't see yet | An inspection with moisture readings and a line-item estimate |
| Deductible | The amount, and whether a separate deductible applies to this cause | The declarations page; your agent |
| Notice | How and by when your policy expects a loss to be reported | The policy's conditions section; your agent or insurer |
| Claims history | How your insurer uses past claims, in your state | Your agent or insurer; your own CLUE report |
| Mitigation | Stopping the damage and keeping receipts | You, whatever you decide |
| Records | Photos, readings, invoices and a call log | You, whatever you decide |
Know the repair cost before you decide
The repair cost is the number the decision starts from, and a first look is a poor guide to it. Water runs inside wall cavities, under flooring and into the subfloor, so the stain you can see can be much smaller than the wet area behind it. Moisture readings, taken room by room, show where the water actually went.
A certified restoration company can inspect, map the moisture, and write an estimate that lists the work line by line: extraction, drying equipment by the day, removal of wet materials, and the rebuild. Ask for the moisture map and photos with the estimate, so you can see what each line is based on. Mitigation and restoration are two different scopes.
- Scope by room, with quantities: square feet of drywall and flooring, linear feet of baseboard, number of days of equipment.
- Moisture readings and where they were taken, including rooms next to the one with visible damage.
- Drying separate from rebuild, so you can see both halves of the cost.
- Photos of the source and of every wet area.
- What was not checked, such as a wall cavity that was not opened. That gap is part of what you are deciding with.
An estimate written before the wet materials come out is a starting point; it can change as walls and floors are opened. What drives the cost of water damage repair.
Your deductible: where to find it, and whether more than one applies
Your deductible is printed on the declarations page, the summary at the front of the policy. The Insurance Information Institute says a deductible can be either a specific dollar amount or a percentage of the total amount of insurance, and that the amount can be found on the declarations (or front) page of a standard homeowners policy.
Some causes of damage carry their own deductible. The Insurance Information Institute says that in hurricane-prone states, special deductibles may apply when damage is attributable to a hurricane, and that wind/hail deductibles are most common in places that typically experience severe windstorms and hail. It says percentage deductibles are calculated on the home's insured value, so ask your agent for the dollar figure on yours.
- Is there one deductible for all causes, or a separate one for wind, hail, hurricane or named storms?
- Is each one a dollar amount or a percentage? If a percentage, what is it in dollars for your home?
- Does any endorsement attached to the policy list its own deductible?
The Insurance Information Institute's own advice is to check your policies and speak to your insurance professional to learn exactly how your deductibles work. Which deductible applies to a particular loss is a question for your agent or insurer.
Notice and timing: waiting has its own costs
Deciding takes time, but the damage and the reporting clock keep running. The NAIC says that if you decide to file a claim, it's important to notify your insurance company right away, and that the amount of time you have to report a claim varies by state. Your policy's conditions section describes how it expects a loss reported.
Two things make waiting costly with water. Damage keeps spreading while materials stay wet, and a loss reported long after it happened has less fresh evidence of when and how it started. The California Department of Insurance warns that homeowners insurance policies may not cover ensuing damage to your property if you have not taken reasonable steps to secure the property from subsequent damage.
Claims history and premiums: a question for your agent
Whether a claim affects your premium depends on your insurer and your state; only your agent or insurer can tell you how theirs works. Regulators publish how claims history is used. Washington's Office of the Insurance Commissioner says an insurer uses your claims history, or a property's, to decide if it'll offer you coverage and how much you'll pay.
That history usually comes from a CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) report, kept by LexisNexis. Washington's insurance commissioner says that if your insurance company starts, denies or pays out a claim, it will submit a CLUE report. It also says LexisNexis advises insurance companies not to report claims information when you contact them to simply ask a question about coverage or your deductible.
The Texas Department of Insurance says insurance companies look at a property's past claims as a factor in deciding how much you'll pay, and gives practical advice for the call: when you're talking to your agent, make sure you're clear about whether you're filing a claim or just asking a question about your policy. TDI also says you can get a free copy of your CLUE report each year from LexisNexis and dispute wrong information.
Stop the damage either way
Mitigation doesn't wait for the decision. Whether or not you file, stop the source, dry what is wet, and keep every receipt. The California Department of Insurance says one of the most important things to do after a property loss is to make temporary repairs to prevent further damage, such as covering openings with plastic sheeting or plywood.
- Stop the source. Close the fixture valve or the main shutoff, or call a plumber. How to shut off the water.
- Photograph before cleanup. The NAIC's advice is to take photos and videos of damage. Get wide shots of each room, close-ups of the source, the water line on walls, and contents in place.
- Start drying. A restoration company extracts standing water, sets drying equipment and takes readings each day until materials are dry. Ask for the daily readings in writing.
- Make temporary repairs. Cap the line, tarp the roof, board the window. Keep the failed part, such as a split supply line or a cracked fitting.
- Keep every receipt. The NAIC says to keep receipts for all repairs and new items you buy, for proof if you have to file a claim.
Document everything, even if you don't file
Keep a complete record whether you file or not. Damage you pay for yourself can come back into view later, as a stain, a warped floor or a musty smell, and you may want to show what happened and what was repaired. Photos, readings and invoices dated now are that record. They are hard to recreate later.
- Dated photos and video, before cleanup and after repairs.
- The moisture map and the drying log, showing when each area read dry.
- The plumber's invoice naming what failed, and the failed part itself.
- Every estimate and final invoice, with the company's name and the dates of work.
- A log of calls, with copies of letters and emails. The California Department of Insurance advises keeping a log of all phone calls and correspondence.
- Photos of any removed drywall, carpet or pad, taken with the moisture readings.
Questions to ask your agent before you decide
Your agent or insurer is the source for anything about your policy and your premium. Ask these before you decide, and write down who answered and when. As the Texas Department of Insurance suggests, be clear at the start of the call about whether you are reporting a claim or just asking questions about your policy.
- What is my deductible for this kind of damage, and does a separate deductible apply to it?
- How, and by when, does my policy expect a loss like this to be reported?
- Is anything recorded on my claims history when I call with questions only?
- If I report the loss and later decide not to pursue it, how is that recorded?
- How does your company use claims history when it renews a policy in this state?
- Do I have a claims-free discount, and how does a claim affect it?
- If more damage turns up after I decide, how would I report it then?
- If I do file, which documents will you want to see?
A side-by-side worksheet
Put the numbers you have next to the questions you can't answer yet. The worksheet has no answer row on purpose: the gap between the estimate and the deductible is one input, not the decision. Fill it in from the written estimate, the declarations page and your agent's answers, then weigh it yourself.
| Item | Your number or answer | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Written repair or restoration estimate | $ | The estimate, with moisture readings and photos |
| Deductible that applies to this cause | $ | The declarations page; your agent |
| The difference (estimate minus deductible) | $ | Your arithmetic |
| Areas not yet opened or measured | The estimate's notes; the moisture map | |
| How your insurer uses claims history | Your agent or insurer | |
| How and by when to report this loss | The policy's conditions; your agent |
There is no row for the answer. The decision is yours to make once the other rows are filled in.
Getting an inspection and a written estimate
If you want a written estimate before you decide, Restoration.com.co connects you, in the areas it serves, with one certified restoration company for your ZIP code; enter your ZIP to see what is available. The company can inspect, take moisture readings and write an estimate. You can also text or call 844-7-RESTORE. For what comes after a decision to file, see the claim, step by step.
Questions people ask
Is it worth filing a claim for water damage?
That depends on facts only you and your agent can put together: a written repair estimate that includes hidden damage, the deductible that applies, and how your insurer uses claims history in your state. This page does not make that call. Gather the estimate and your agent's answers, then decide.
Will my rates go up if I file a claim?
It varies by insurer and by state, and your agent or insurer is the only accurate source. Washington's insurance commissioner says insurers use claims history to decide whether to offer coverage and how much you'll pay. Ask how your insurer applies it before you decide.
Does calling my insurer with a question count as a claim?
Washington's insurance commissioner says LexisNexis advises insurers not to report claims information when you simply ask a question about coverage or your deductible. The Texas Department of Insurance suggests making clear whether you are filing a claim or just asking a question. If you are unsure how your insurer records calls, ask at the start.
What if the repair estimate is close to my deductible?
Then the comparison is one fact in front of you, along with what the estimate could not see yet. Water inside walls and under floors can make an early estimate low. Ask your agent how your policy expects the loss reported, and keep your records either way.
Should I start repairs before I decide?
Stop the damage now, whatever you decide: temporary repairs, drying and receipts. Photograph everything before it is removed, and keep the failed part. Permanent repairs can wait until you have the estimate and your agent's answers.
How long can I take to decide?
The NAIC says the amount of time you have to report a claim varies by state, and your policy sets its own conditions for reporting. Ask your agent. The damage keeps spreading while materials stay wet, so mitigation comes first.
